Reviews

We Value Your Feedback!

At Troni Brothers, we take pride in serving delicious food and providing a great experience at each of our locations. If you’ve recently visited us, we’d love to hear from you!

⭐ Read what others are saying about their experience and see why our customers keep coming back for more!

👍 Had a great visit? Help us spread the love by leaving a positive review for the location you visited. Your feedback means the world to us and helps others discover their new favorite pizza spot!

Thank you for your support—we look forward to serving you again soon! 🍕
Click below to read or leave a review:
Matt E. profile picture
Matt E.
2 months ago
Everything I've had here is delicious, Everytime without fail. I personally recommend the fra diavolo.
Keith W. profile picture
Keith W.
2 months ago
Crazy good food, huge portions, very reasonable prices, and the staff was fantastic! From being greeted at the door to the table service…simply fantastic. A great dinner stop while riding the OTET from Cinci to Cleveland.
Sandy M. profile picture
Sandy M.
2 months ago
This is such a great place to eat. The food is exceptional and the portions are huge! The best part is Hale our favorite server. He is very friendly, professional and attentive. He’s the best.
trudy T. profile picture
trudy T.
4 months ago
Fantastic authentic Italian. It's hard to find a place like this. The "rolls" that they bring out with your side salad (part of the meal) are dripping in a melted fresh garlic butter. They are garlic knots that are made out of a very good dough. They were a pleasant surprise! For a "pizza joint" type feel the salad was impressive! It was actually COLD and crisp and had thin sliced red onion...would not have expected such a good salad. Look at the photos, the baked pasta dishes swimming in sauce and the right amount of cheese bubbled perfectly on top. OMG. Soooooo good . And for this Diet Coke girlie, they have COCA COLA products, waiter kept my Diet Coke filled. Great service. Super down to earth friendly staff..
Chris T profile picture
Chris T
5 months ago
This place is fantastic, the food here is just spectacular, the pizza, the pasta dishes, chicken parmigiana and linguine with white clam sauce are my favorites..The wait staff and owner are always so friendly, they joke around and if you tease them they give it right back. There is a smell, but if you’re familiar with the area it’s from the creek/river behind the building, the restaurant is actually very clean. I have never been disappointed with anything I have ever ordered here. It may cost a bit more than the chain places, but one bite and you’ll see why, they could triple their prices and I’d keep coming back! Five stars…I’d give them five hundred if I could! Give them a try, you will NOT be disappointed!!!
Bill G. profile picture
Bill G.
10 months ago
Stopped in on a fly one night wanting some Italian! Glad I did! Staff was very accommodating! Drinks and food were great! The Lasagna and Trio was perfect, Salad was okay! Could do some work! Definitely give them a shot if you are around!
Scott N. profile picture
Scott N.
11 months ago
The pizza was a decent NY style pie, the crust was crisp around the edge, the bottom was a little soft. Good sauce, I got extra (my usual) and great cheese, and a nice amount of toppings (half pepperoni/half ham). The garlic rolls (not knots) were very good, seasoned well with garlic and parmesan. My server Sarah was great, she was friendly and helpful when ordering (1st time), and provided great service. The location sits back off the road, so you have to look for it, but it was a nice place to enjoy a pizza after seeing the Christmas lights at Caesar Ford Park. Got a piece of Lemoncello cake to go, it was delicious and refreshing.
Kelley M. profile picture
Kelley M.
2 years ago
Hale was amazing and the food was delicious!
Zachary W. profile picture
Zachary W.
2 years ago
I've always had great service and good food . Esp the chicken Alfredo...
Benny P. profile picture
Benny P.
2 years ago
Best pizza we've had in a long time, our server was excellent. Very clean with friendly service
Clayton S. profile picture
Clayton S.
2 years ago
Stopped by for lunch and the food was very good atmosphere was good, the service was absolutely amazing. Our waitress Sherrie went above and beyond expectations, highly recommend. Take my advice, ask for Sherrie’s section if she there, you won’t be disappointed
Rachel E. profile picture
Rachel E.
2 years ago
I had the absolute pleasure of dining at Troni Brothers Italian Restaurant in Xenia, Ohio, on Valentine's Day, 02/14/2025 and I can honestly say it was one of the best dining experiences I've ever had!
Our waiter, Hale, was nothing short of exceptional. He greeted us with a genuine smile and immediately made us feel welcome. His attentiveness and knowledge of the menu truly enhanced our experience. Hale recommended some fantastic dishes, and his suggestions did not disappoint!
Not only was the food outstanding, but Hale's impeccable service made the night even more special. He was attentive without being intrusive, ensuring I had everything I needed while also engaging in friendly conversation. It's clear that he genuinely cares about his guests and wants to provide them with the best possible experience.
Overall, Troni Brothers is a gem in Xenia, and I can't recommend it enough! Thank you, Hale, for making Valentine's dinner unforgettable!
Jona K. profile picture
Jona K.
2 years ago
Huge portions of delicious options delivered quickly. Savannah was very attentive and made the overall experience enjoyable. We're so happy we stumbled upon this gem!
Brandt K. profile picture
Brandt K.
2 years ago
Got the Spinich Roll, and I was NOT disappointed. Our server Savanah was lovely, and our food was out in roughly 10 minutes.
Josh profile picture
Josh
2 years ago
First time eating at Troni Brothers Italian Restaurant tonight. Was very delicious. I ordered the spaghetti with marinara sauce and added meatballs. Came with a nice-sized garden salad and two garlic rolls. Don’t let the price fool you. I was a little hesitant because spaghetti and meatballs are $18, but the portion sizes are huge. For me, I could probably get three meals out of the plate. I ate a good portion and when I was full it looked like I hadn’t even touched the plate. Marinara sauce was very good - the perfect amount of tang and not sweet. The meatballs were good, easy to cut through with a fork.

My wife got fettuccine alfredo with chicken and the portion size was just as big.

Strongly recommend.
Donny B. profile picture
Donny B.
3 years ago
First of all kudos to our server "Sarah" who made sure everything was okay with our food and kept our drinks filled and accommodated us with everything we asked for, the whole staff here is super friendly, I had the pizza with mushroom, sausage and pineapple, it was full of flavor and you could taste it in each topping, and all the toppings were fresh. My sister had the lobster ravioli and she said it was full of lobster and flavorful, and she also had a side salad. The food here is cooked to perfection and it's a great atmosphere for the whole family. I highly recommend this place!
More reviews